2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<?xml version='1.0'?> <!-- * - nxml - * -->
< !DOCTYPE refentry PUBLIC "-//OASIS//DTD DocBook XML V4.5//EN"
2023-12-25 17:48:33 +03:00
"http://www.oasis-open.org/docbook/xml/4.5/docbookx.dtd">
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<!-- SPDX - License - Identifier: LGPL - 2.1 - or - later -->
2023-02-26 16:09:44 +03:00
<refentry id= "systemd-stub" conditional= 'ENABLE_BOOTLOADER'
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
xmlns:xi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XInclude">
<refentryinfo >
<title > systemd-stub</title>
<productname > systemd</productname>
</refentryinfo>
<refmeta >
<refentrytitle > systemd-stub</refentrytitle>
<manvolnum > 7</manvolnum>
</refmeta>
<refnamediv >
<refname > systemd-stub</refname>
2022-03-22 02:19:32 +03:00
<refname > sd-stub</refname>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<refname > linuxx64.efi.stub</refname>
<refname > linuxia32.efi.stub</refname>
<refname > linuxaa64.efi.stub</refname>
<refpurpose > A simple UEFI kernel boot stub</refpurpose>
</refnamediv>
<refsynopsisdiv >
2023-12-14 14:52:03 +03:00
<para > <simplelist >
<member > <filename > /usr/lib/systemd/boot/efi/linuxx64.efi.stub</filename> </member>
<member > <filename > /usr/lib/systemd/boot/efi/linuxia32.efi.stub</filename> </member>
<member > <filename > /usr/lib/systemd/boot/efi/linuxaa64.efi.stub</filename> </member>
<member > <filename > <replaceable > ESP</replaceable> /.../<replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/*.addon.efi</filename> </member>
<member > <filename > <replaceable > ESP</replaceable> /.../<replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/*.cred</filename> </member>
<member > <filename > <replaceable > ESP</replaceable> /.../<replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/*.raw</filename> </member>
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
<member > <filename > <replaceable > ESP</replaceable> /.../<replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/*.sysext.raw</filename> </member>
<member > <filename > <replaceable > ESP</replaceable> /.../<replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/*.confext.raw</filename> </member>
2023-12-14 14:52:03 +03:00
<member > <filename > <replaceable > ESP</replaceable> /loader/addons/*.addon.efi</filename> </member>
<member > <filename > <replaceable > ESP</replaceable> /loader/credentials/*.cred</filename> </member>
</simplelist> </para>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</refsynopsisdiv>
<refsect1 >
<title > Description</title>
<para > <command > systemd-stub</command> (stored in per-architecture files
<filename > linuxx64.efi.stub</filename> , <filename > linuxia32.efi.stub</filename> ,
<filename > linuxaa64.efi.stub</filename> on disk) is a simple UEFI boot stub. An UEFI boot stub is
attached to a Linux kernel binary image, and is a piece of code that runs in the UEFI firmware
environment before transitioning into the Linux kernel environment. The UEFI boot stub ensures a Linux
kernel is executable as regular UEFI binary, and is able to do various preparations before switching the
system into the Linux world.</para>
<para > The UEFI boot stub looks for various resources for the kernel invocation inside the UEFI PE binary
2024-10-03 13:52:56 +03:00
itself. This allows combining various resources inside a single PE binary image (a "Unified Kernel Image"
or "UKI" for short), which may then be signed via UEFI SecureBoot as a whole, covering all individual
resources at once. Specifically it may include the following PE sections:</para>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<itemizedlist >
2023-09-18 12:08:55 +03:00
<!-- Let's keep this in the canonical order we also measure the sections by, i.e. as in
src/fundamental/uki.h's UnifiedSection enum -->
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > A <literal > .linux</literal> section with the ELF Linux kernel image.
This section is required.</para> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .osrel</literal> section with OS release information, i.e. the
contents of the
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > os-release</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 5</manvolnum> </citerefentry> file of
the OS the kernel belongs to.</para> </listitem>
efi: from the stub measure the ELF kernel + built-in initrd and so on into PCR 11
Here we grab a new – on Linux so far unused (by my Googling skills, that
is) – and measure all static components of the PE kernel image into.
This is useful since for the first time we'll have a PCR that contains
only a PCR of the booted kernel, nothing else. That allows putting
together TPM policies that bind to a specific kernel (+ builtin initrd),
without having to have booted that kernel first. PCRs can be
pre-calculated. Yay!
You might wonder, why we measure just the discovered PE sections we are
about to use, instead of the whole PE image. That's because of the next
step I have in mind: PE images should also be able to carry an
additional section that contains a signature for its own expected,
pre-calculated PCR values. This signature data should then be passed
into the booted kernel and can be used there in TPM policies. Benefit:
TPM policies can now be bound to *signatures* of PCRs, instead of the
raw hash values themselves. This makes update management a *lot* easier,
as policies don't need to be updated whenever a kernel is updated, as
long as the signature is available. Now, if the PCR signature is
embedded in the kernel PE image it cannot be of a PCR hash of the kernel
PE image itself, because that would be a chicken-and-egg problem. Hence,
by only measuring the relavent payload sections (and that means
excluding the future section that will contain the PCR hash signature)
we avoid this problem, naturally.
2022-07-25 18:44:24 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .cmdline</literal> section with the kernel command line to pass to
the invoked kernel.</para> </listitem>
2023-09-18 12:08:55 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .initrd</literal> section with the initrd.</para> </listitem>
2023-05-21 16:32:09 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .ucode</literal> section with an initrd containing microcode, to
be handed to the kernel before any other initrd. This initrd must not be compressed.</para> </listitem>
2024-04-02 13:54:30 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .splash</literal> section with an image (in the Windows
2023-11-24 17:19:50 +03:00
<filename > .BMP</filename> format) to show on screen before invoking the kernel.</para> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .dtb</literal> section with a compiled binary DeviceTree.
</para> </listitem>
<listitem > <para > Zero or more <literal > .dtbauto</literal> sections. <filename > systemd-stub</filename>
will always use the first matching one. The match is performed by taking the first DeviceTree's
<varname > compatible</varname> string supplied by the firmware in configuration tables and comparing it
with the first <varname > compatible</varname> string from each of the <literal > .dtbauto</literal>
sections. If the firmware does not provide a DeviceTree, the match is done using the
<varname > .hwids</varname> section instead. After selecting a <literal > .hwids</literal> section (see the
description below), the <varname > compatible</varname> string from that section will be used to perform
the same matching procedure. If a match is found, that <literal > .dtbauto</literal> section will be
2024-10-22 15:07:15 +03:00
loaded and will override <varname > .dtb</varname> if present.</para> </listitem>
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > Zero or more <literal > .hwids</literal> sections with hardware IDs of the machines to
match DeviceTrees. <filename > systemd-stub</filename> will use the SMBIOS data to calculate hardware IDs
of the machine (as per <ulink
url="https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/install/specifying-hardware-ids-for-a-computer">specification</ulink> ),
and then it will try to find any of them in each of the <literal > .hwids</literal> sections. The first
matching section will be used.</para> </listitem>
2024-10-22 15:07:15 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .uname</literal> section with the kernel version information, i.e.
the output of <command > uname -r</command> for the kernel included in the <literal > .linux</literal>
2023-11-24 17:19:50 +03:00
section.</para> </listitem>
2023-05-21 17:18:21 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .sbat</literal> section with
<ulink url= "https://github.com/rhboot/shim/blob/main/SBAT.md" > SBAT</ulink> revocation metadata.
</para> </listitem>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .pcrsig</literal> section with a set of cryptographic signatures
for the expected TPM2 PCR values after the kernel has been booted, in JSON format. This is useful for
2023-11-24 17:19:50 +03:00
implementing TPM2 policies that bind disk encryption and similar to kernels that are signed by a
specific key.</para> </listitem>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<listitem > <para > An optional <literal > .pcrpkey</literal> section with a public key in the PEM format
matching the signature data in the <literal > .pcrsig</literal> section.</para> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</itemizedlist>
2024-11-06 16:40:21 +03:00
<!-- FIXME: how does .dtauto/.hwids matching interact with profiles? -->
<para > In a basic UKI, the sections listed above appear at most once, with the exception of
<literal > .dtbauto</literal> and <literal > .hwids</literal> sections. In a multi-profile UKI,
2024-10-03 13:52:56 +03:00
multiple sets of these sections are present in a single file and form "profiles",
one of which can be selected at boot. For this, the PE section <literal > .profile</literal> is
defined to be used as the separator between sets of sections. The
stub: add ability to place multiple alternative PE sections of a specific type in the same UKI ("Multi-Profile UKIs")
This adds a ability to add alternative sections of a specific type in
the same UKI. The primary usecase is for supporting multiple different
kernel cmdlines that are baked into a UKI.
The mechanism is relatively simple (I think), in order to make it robust.
1. A new PE section ".profile" is introduced, that is a lot like
".osrel", but contains information about a specific "profile" to
boot. The ".profile" section can appear multiple times in the same
PE, and acts as delimiter indicating where a new profile starts.
Everything before the first ".profile" is called the "base profile",
and is shared among all other profiles, which can then override or
add addition PE sections on top.
2. An UKI's command line can be prefixed with an argument such as "@0" or
"@1" or "@2" which indicates the "profile" to boot. If no argument is
specified the default is profile 0. Also, a UKI that lacks any
.profile section is treated like one with only a profile 0, but with
no data in that profile section.
3. The stub will first search for its usual set of PE sections
(hereafter called "base sections"), and stop at the first .profile PE
section if any. It will then find the .profile matching the selected
profile by its index, and any sections found as part of that profile
on top of the base sections.
And that's already it.
Example: let's say a distro wants to provide a single UKI that can be
invoked in one of three ways:
1. The regular profile that just boots the system
2. A profile that boots into storagetm
3. A profile that initiates factory reset and reboots.
For this it would define a classic UKI with sections .linux, .initrd,
.cmdline, and whatever else it needs. The .cmdline section would contain
the kernel command line for the regular profile.
It would then insert one ".profile" section, with a contents like the
following:
ID=regular
This is the profile for profile 0. It would immediately afterwards add
another ".profile" section:
ID=storagetm
TITLE=Boot into Storage Target Mode
This would then followed with a .cmdline section that is just like the
basic one, but with "rd.systemd.unit=storage-target-mode.target"
suffixed. Then, another .profile section would be added:
ID=factory-reset
TITLE=Factory Reset
Which is then followed by one last PE section: a .cmdline one with
"systemd.unit=factory-reset.target" suffixed to te regular command line.
i.e. expressed in tabular form the above would be:
The base profile:
.linux
.initrd
.cmdline
.osrel
The regular boot profile:
.profile
The storagetm profile:
.profile
.cmdline
The factory reset profile:
.profile
.cmdline
You might wonder why the first .cmdline in the list above is placed in
the base profile rather than in the regular boot profile, given that it
is overriden in all other profiles anyway. And you are right. The only
reason I'd place it in the base profile is that it makes the UKI more
nicely extensible if later profiles are added that want to replace
something else instead of the .cmdline, for example .ucode or so. But it
really doesn't matter much.
While the primary usecase is of course multiple alternative command
lines, the concept is more powerful than that: for various usecases it
might be valuable to offer multiple choices of devicetree, ucode or
initrds.
The .profile contents is also passed to the invoked kernel as a file in
/.extra/profile (via a synthetic initrd). Thus, this functionality can
even be useful without overriding any section at all, simply by means of
reading that file from userspace.
Design choices:
1. On purposes I used a special command line marker (i.e. the "@" thing,
which maybe we should call the "profile selector"), that doesn't look
like a regular kernel command line option. This is because this is
really not a regular kernel command line option – we process it in
the stub, then remove it as prefix, and measure the unprefixed
command line only after that. The kernel will not see the profile
selector either. I think these special semantics are best
communicated by making it look substantially different from regular
options.
2. This moves around measurements a bit. Previously we measured our UKI
sections right after finding them. Now we first parse the profile
number from the command line, then search for the profile's sections,
and only then measure the sections we actually end up using for this
profile. I think that this logic makes most sense: measure what we
are using, not what we are overriding. Or in other words, if you boot
profile @3, then we'll measure .cmdline (assuming it exists) of
profile 3, and *not* measure .cmdline of the base profile. Also note
that if the user passes in a custom kernel command line via command
line arguments we'll strip off the profile selector (i.e. the initial
"@X" thing) before we pass it on.
3. The .profile stuff is supposed to be generic and extensible. For
example we could use it in future to mark "dangerous" options such as
factory reset, so that boot menus can ask for confirmation before
booting into it. Or we could introduce match expressions against
SMBIOS or other system identifiers, to filter out profiles on
specific hw.
Note btw, that PE allows defining multiple sections that point to the
same offsets in the file. This allows sharing payload under different
names. For example, if profile @4 and @7 shall carry the same .ucode
section, they can define .ucode in each profile and then make it point to
the same offset.
Also note that that one can even "mask" a base section in a profile, by
inserting an empty section. For example, if the base .dtb section should
not be used for profile @4, then add a section .dtb right after the
fourth .profile with a zero size to the UKI, and you will get your wish
fulfilled.
This code only contains changes to sd-stub. A follow-up commit will
teach sd-boot to also find this profile PE sections to synthesize
additional menu entries from a single UKI.
A later commit will add support for gnerating this via ukify.
Fixes: #24539
2024-06-27 23:21:58 +03:00
<literal > .profile</literal> section itself may contain meta-information about the section, and follows a
similar structure as the contents of the <literal > .osrel</literal> section. For further details about
multi-profile UKIs, see below.</para> <para > If UEFI SecureBoot is enabled and the
<literal > .cmdline</literal> section is present in the executed image, any attempts to override the kernel
command line by passing one as invocation parameters to the EFI binary are ignored. Thus, in order to
allow overriding the kernel command line, either disable UEFI SecureBoot, or don't include a kernel
command line PE section in the kernel image file. If a command line is accepted via EFI invocation
parameters to the EFI binary it is measured into TPM PCR 12 (if a TPM is present).</para> <para > If a
DeviceTree is embedded in the <literal > .dtb</literal> section, it replaces an existing DeviceTree in the
corresponding EFI configuration table. systemd-stub will ask the firmware via the
<literal > EFI_DT_FIXUP_PROTOCOL</literal> for hardware specific fixups to the DeviceTree.</para> <para > The
contents of 11 of these 12 sections are measured into TPM PCR 11. It is otherwise not used and thus the
result can be pre-calculated without too much effort. The <literal > .pcrsig</literal> section is not
included in this PCR measurement, since it is supposed to contain signatures for the output of the
measurement operation, and thus cannot also be input to it. If an UKI contains multiple profiles, only
2024-09-16 05:49:02 +03:00
the PE sections of the selected profile (and those of the base profile, except if overridden) are
stub: add ability to place multiple alternative PE sections of a specific type in the same UKI ("Multi-Profile UKIs")
This adds a ability to add alternative sections of a specific type in
the same UKI. The primary usecase is for supporting multiple different
kernel cmdlines that are baked into a UKI.
The mechanism is relatively simple (I think), in order to make it robust.
1. A new PE section ".profile" is introduced, that is a lot like
".osrel", but contains information about a specific "profile" to
boot. The ".profile" section can appear multiple times in the same
PE, and acts as delimiter indicating where a new profile starts.
Everything before the first ".profile" is called the "base profile",
and is shared among all other profiles, which can then override or
add addition PE sections on top.
2. An UKI's command line can be prefixed with an argument such as "@0" or
"@1" or "@2" which indicates the "profile" to boot. If no argument is
specified the default is profile 0. Also, a UKI that lacks any
.profile section is treated like one with only a profile 0, but with
no data in that profile section.
3. The stub will first search for its usual set of PE sections
(hereafter called "base sections"), and stop at the first .profile PE
section if any. It will then find the .profile matching the selected
profile by its index, and any sections found as part of that profile
on top of the base sections.
And that's already it.
Example: let's say a distro wants to provide a single UKI that can be
invoked in one of three ways:
1. The regular profile that just boots the system
2. A profile that boots into storagetm
3. A profile that initiates factory reset and reboots.
For this it would define a classic UKI with sections .linux, .initrd,
.cmdline, and whatever else it needs. The .cmdline section would contain
the kernel command line for the regular profile.
It would then insert one ".profile" section, with a contents like the
following:
ID=regular
This is the profile for profile 0. It would immediately afterwards add
another ".profile" section:
ID=storagetm
TITLE=Boot into Storage Target Mode
This would then followed with a .cmdline section that is just like the
basic one, but with "rd.systemd.unit=storage-target-mode.target"
suffixed. Then, another .profile section would be added:
ID=factory-reset
TITLE=Factory Reset
Which is then followed by one last PE section: a .cmdline one with
"systemd.unit=factory-reset.target" suffixed to te regular command line.
i.e. expressed in tabular form the above would be:
The base profile:
.linux
.initrd
.cmdline
.osrel
The regular boot profile:
.profile
The storagetm profile:
.profile
.cmdline
The factory reset profile:
.profile
.cmdline
You might wonder why the first .cmdline in the list above is placed in
the base profile rather than in the regular boot profile, given that it
is overriden in all other profiles anyway. And you are right. The only
reason I'd place it in the base profile is that it makes the UKI more
nicely extensible if later profiles are added that want to replace
something else instead of the .cmdline, for example .ucode or so. But it
really doesn't matter much.
While the primary usecase is of course multiple alternative command
lines, the concept is more powerful than that: for various usecases it
might be valuable to offer multiple choices of devicetree, ucode or
initrds.
The .profile contents is also passed to the invoked kernel as a file in
/.extra/profile (via a synthetic initrd). Thus, this functionality can
even be useful without overriding any section at all, simply by means of
reading that file from userspace.
Design choices:
1. On purposes I used a special command line marker (i.e. the "@" thing,
which maybe we should call the "profile selector"), that doesn't look
like a regular kernel command line option. This is because this is
really not a regular kernel command line option – we process it in
the stub, then remove it as prefix, and measure the unprefixed
command line only after that. The kernel will not see the profile
selector either. I think these special semantics are best
communicated by making it look substantially different from regular
options.
2. This moves around measurements a bit. Previously we measured our UKI
sections right after finding them. Now we first parse the profile
number from the command line, then search for the profile's sections,
and only then measure the sections we actually end up using for this
profile. I think that this logic makes most sense: measure what we
are using, not what we are overriding. Or in other words, if you boot
profile @3, then we'll measure .cmdline (assuming it exists) of
profile 3, and *not* measure .cmdline of the base profile. Also note
that if the user passes in a custom kernel command line via command
line arguments we'll strip off the profile selector (i.e. the initial
"@X" thing) before we pass it on.
3. The .profile stuff is supposed to be generic and extensible. For
example we could use it in future to mark "dangerous" options such as
factory reset, so that boot menus can ask for confirmation before
booting into it. Or we could introduce match expressions against
SMBIOS or other system identifiers, to filter out profiles on
specific hw.
Note btw, that PE allows defining multiple sections that point to the
same offsets in the file. This allows sharing payload under different
names. For example, if profile @4 and @7 shall carry the same .ucode
section, they can define .ucode in each profile and then make it point to
the same offset.
Also note that that one can even "mask" a base section in a profile, by
inserting an empty section. For example, if the base .dtb section should
not be used for profile @4, then add a section .dtb right after the
fourth .profile with a zero size to the UKI, and you will get your wish
fulfilled.
This code only contains changes to sd-stub. A follow-up commit will
teach sd-boot to also find this profile PE sections to synthesize
additional menu entries from a single UKI.
A later commit will add support for gnerating this via ukify.
Fixes: #24539
2024-06-27 23:21:58 +03:00
measured.</para>
<para > If non-zero, the selected numeric profile is measured into PCR 12.</para>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
2023-11-24 17:19:50 +03:00
<para > When <literal > .pcrsig</literal> and/or <literal > .pcrpkey</literal> sections are present in a
unified kernel image their contents are passed to the booted kernel in an synthetic initrd cpio archive
that places them in the <filename > /.extra/tpm2-pcr-signature.json</filename> and
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
<filename > /.extra/tpm2-pcr-public-key.pem</filename> files. Typically, a
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > tmpfiles.d</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 5</manvolnum> </citerefentry> line then
ensures they are copied into <filename > /run/systemd/tpm2-pcr-signature.json</filename> and
<filename > /run/systemd/tpm2-pcr-public-key.pem</filename> where they remain accessible even after the
system transitions out of the initrd environment into the host file system. Tools such
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-cryptsetup@.service</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 8</manvolnum> </citerefentry> ,
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-cryptenroll</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry>
and <citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-creds</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry>
will automatically use files present under these paths to unlock protected resources (encrypted storage
or credentials) or bind encryption to booted kernels.</para>
2023-09-18 12:19:17 +03:00
<para > For further details about the UKI concept, see the <ulink
url="https://uapi-group.org/specifications/specs/unified_kernel_image/">UKI specification</ulink> .</para>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</refsect1>
<refsect1 >
<title > Companion Files</title>
2023-09-18 12:19:26 +03:00
<para > The <command > systemd-stub</command> UEFI boot stub automatically collects three types of auxiliary
2021-12-08 05:21:40 +03:00
companion files optionally placed in drop-in directories on the same partition as the EFI binary,
dynamically generates <command > cpio</command> initrd archives from them, and passes them to the kernel.
Specifically:</para>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<itemizedlist >
2021-12-08 05:21:40 +03:00
<listitem > <para > For a kernel binary called <filename > <replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi</filename> , it
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
will look for files with the <filename > .cred</filename> suffix in a directory named
2023-10-20 00:13:45 +03:00
<filename > <replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/</filename> next to it. If the kernel binary
uses a counter for the purpose of
<ulink url= "https://systemd.io/AUTOMATIC_BOOT_ASSESSMENT" > Automatic Boot Assessment</ulink> , this
counter will be ignored. For example, <filename > <replaceable > foo</replaceable> +3-0.efi</filename>
will look in directory <filename > <replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/</filename> .
A <command > cpio</command>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
archive is generated from all files found that way, placing them in the
<filename > /.extra/credentials/</filename> directory of the initrd file hierarchy. The main initrd may
then access them in this directory. This is supposed to be used to store auxiliary, encrypted,
authenticated credentials for use with <varname > LoadCredentialEncrypted=</varname> in the UEFI System
Partition. See
2022-02-23 00:54:23 +03:00
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd.exec</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 5</manvolnum> </citerefentry>
and
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-creds</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry>
for
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
details on encrypted credentials. The generated <command > cpio</command> archive is measured into TPM
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
PCR 12 (if a TPM is present).</para> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
<listitem > <para > Similarly, files
<filename > <replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/*.sysext.raw</filename> are packed up in a
<command > cpio</command> archive and placed in the <filename > /.extra/sysext/</filename> directory in the
initrd file hierarchy. This is supposed to be used to pass additional system extension images to the
initrd. See
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-sysext</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 8</manvolnum> </citerefentry> for
details on system extension images. The generated <command > cpio</command> archive containing these
sd-stub: measure sysext images picked up by sd-stub into PCR 13
Let's grab another so far unused PCR, and measure all sysext images into
it that we load from the ESP. Note that this is possibly partly redundant,
since sysext images should have dm-verity enabled, and that is hooked up
to IMA. However, measuring this explicitly has the benefit that we can
measure filenames too, easily, and that all without need for IMA or
anything like that.
This means: when booting a unified sd-stub kernel through sd-boot we'll
now have:
1. PCR 11: unified kernel image payload (i.e. kernel, initrd, boot
splash, dtb, osrelease)
2. PCR 12: kernel command line (i.e. the one embedded in the image, plus
optionally an overriden one) + any credential files picked up by
sd-stub
3. PCR 13: sysext images picked up by sd-stub
And each of these three PCRs should carry just the above, and start from
zero, thus be pre-calculatable.
Thus, all components and parameters of the OS boot process (i.e.
everything after the boot loader) is now nicely pre-calculable.
NOTE: this actually replaces previous measuring of the syext images into
PCR 4. I added this back in 845707aae23b3129db635604edb95c4048a5922a,
following the train of thought, that sysext images for the initrd should
be measured like the initrd itself they are for, and according to my
thinking that would be a unified kernel which is measured by firmware
into PCR 4 like any other UEFI executables.
However, I think we should depart from that idea. First and foremost
that makes it harder to pre-calculate PCR 4 (since we actually measured
quite incompatible records to the TPM event log), but also I think
there's great value in being able to write policies that bind to the
used sysexts independently of the earlier boot chain (i.e. shim, boot
loader, unified kernel), hence a separate PCR makes more sense.
Strictly speaking, this is a compatibility break, but I think one we can
get away with, simply because the initrd sysext images are currently not
picked up by systemd-sysext yet in the initrd, and because of that we
can be reasonably sure noone uses this yet, and hence relies on the PCR
register used. Hence, let's clean this up before people actually do
start relying on this.
2022-07-26 12:35:57 +03:00
system extension images is measured into TPM PCR 13 (if a TPM is present).</para> </listitem>
2021-12-08 05:21:40 +03:00
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
<!-- Note: the actual suffix we look for for sysexts is just *.raw (not *.sysext.raw), for
compatibility reasons with old versions. But we want people to name their system extensions
properly, hence we document the *.sysext.raw suffix only. -->
<listitem > <para > Similarly, files
<filename > <replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/*.confext.raw</filename> are packed up in a
<command > cpio</command> archive and placed in the <filename > /.extra/confext/</filename> directory in
the initrd file hierarchy. This is supposed to be used to pass additional configuration extension
images to the initrd. See
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-confext</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 8</manvolnum> </citerefentry> for
details on configuration extension images. The generated <command > cpio</command> archive containing
2024-11-23 16:07:56 +03:00
these configuration extension images is measured into TPM PCR 12 (if a TPM is present).</para> </listitem>
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
2023-05-12 02:55:58 +03:00
<listitem > <para > Similarly, files
2023-11-06 17:02:51 +03:00
<filename > <replaceable > foo</replaceable> .efi.extra.d/*.addon.efi</filename> are loaded and verified as
2024-10-03 13:52:56 +03:00
PE binaries and specific sections are loaded from them. Addons are used to pass additional kernel
2024-11-06 16:45:43 +03:00
command line parameters (<literal > .cmdline</literal> section), or DeviceTree blobs
2024-10-08 17:54:43 +03:00
(<literal > .dtb</literal> section), additional initrds (<literal > .initrd</literal> section),
and microcode updates (<literal > .ucode</literal> section). Addons allow those resources to be passed
regardless of the kernel version being booted, for example allowing platform vendors to ship
platform-specific configuration.</para>
2023-11-06 17:02:51 +03:00
<para > In case Secure Boot is enabled, these files will be validated using keys in UEFI DB, Shim's DB or
2024-10-03 13:52:56 +03:00
Shim's MOK, and only loaded if the check passes. Additionally, if both the addon and the UKI contain a
2023-11-06 17:02:51 +03:00
<literal > .uname</literal> section, the addon will be rejected if they do not match exactly. It is
2023-05-12 02:55:58 +03:00
recommended to always add a <literal > .sbat</literal> section to all signed addons, so that they may be
revoked with a SBAT policy update, without requiring blocklisting via DBX/MOKX. The
2023-11-06 17:02:51 +03:00
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > ukify</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> tool will add
a SBAT policy by default if none is passed when building addons. For more information on SBAT see
<ulink url= "https://github.com/rhboot/shim/blob/main/SBAT.md" > Shim documentation</ulink> .</para>
<para > Addon files are sorted, loaded, and measured into TPM PCR 12 (if a TPM is present) and appended
to the kernel command line. UKI command line options are listed first, then options from addons in
<filename > /loader/addons/*.addon.efi</filename> , and finally UKI-specific addons. Device tree blobs are
2024-07-03 15:13:29 +03:00
loaded and measured following the same algorithm. Microcode addons are passed to the kernel in inverse
order (UKI specific addons, global addons, UKI embedded section). This is because the microcode update
driver stops on the first matching filename. Addons are always loaded in the same order based on
2023-11-06 17:02:51 +03:00
the filename, so that, given the same set of addons, the same set of measurements can be expected in
PCR12. However, note that the filename is not protected by the PE signature, and as such an attacker
with write access to the ESP could potentially rename these files to change the order in which they are
loaded, in a way that could alter the functionality of the kernel, as some options might be
order-dependent. If you sign such addons, you should pay attention to the PCR12 values and make use of
an attestation service so that improper use of your signed addons can be detected and dealt with using
one of the aforementioned revocation mechanisms.</para> </listitem>
2023-05-12 02:55:58 +03:00
2021-12-08 05:21:40 +03:00
<listitem > <para > Files <filename > /loader/credentials/*.cred</filename> are packed up in a
<command > cpio</command> archive and placed in the <filename > /.extra/global_credentials/</filename>
directory of the initrd file hierarchy. This is supposed to be used to pass additional credentials to
2024-10-03 13:52:56 +03:00
the initrd, regardless of the kernel version being booted. The generated <command > cpio</command>
archive is measured into TPM PCR 12 (if a TPM is present).</para> </listitem>
2023-05-12 02:55:58 +03:00
<listitem > <para > Additionally, files <filename > /loader/addons/*.addon.efi</filename> are loaded and
2024-10-08 17:54:43 +03:00
verified as PE binaries, and <literal > .cmdline</literal> , <literal > .dtb</literal> ,
<literal > .initrd</literal> , and <literal > .ucode</literal> sections are parsed from them.
This is supposed to be used to pass additional command line parameters, DeviceTree blobs, initrds,
and microcode updates to the kernel, regardless of the kernel version being booted.</para> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</itemizedlist>
2021-12-08 05:21:40 +03:00
<para > These mechanisms may be used to parameterize and extend trusted (i.e. signed), immutable initrd
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
images in a reasonably safe way: all data they contain is measured into TPM PCRs. On access they should be
further validated: in case of the credentials case by encrypting/authenticating them via TPM, as exposed
by <command > systemd-creds encrypt -T</command> (see
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-creds</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> for
details); in case of the system extension images by using signed Verity images.</para>
</refsect1>
stub: add ability to place multiple alternative PE sections of a specific type in the same UKI ("Multi-Profile UKIs")
This adds a ability to add alternative sections of a specific type in
the same UKI. The primary usecase is for supporting multiple different
kernel cmdlines that are baked into a UKI.
The mechanism is relatively simple (I think), in order to make it robust.
1. A new PE section ".profile" is introduced, that is a lot like
".osrel", but contains information about a specific "profile" to
boot. The ".profile" section can appear multiple times in the same
PE, and acts as delimiter indicating where a new profile starts.
Everything before the first ".profile" is called the "base profile",
and is shared among all other profiles, which can then override or
add addition PE sections on top.
2. An UKI's command line can be prefixed with an argument such as "@0" or
"@1" or "@2" which indicates the "profile" to boot. If no argument is
specified the default is profile 0. Also, a UKI that lacks any
.profile section is treated like one with only a profile 0, but with
no data in that profile section.
3. The stub will first search for its usual set of PE sections
(hereafter called "base sections"), and stop at the first .profile PE
section if any. It will then find the .profile matching the selected
profile by its index, and any sections found as part of that profile
on top of the base sections.
And that's already it.
Example: let's say a distro wants to provide a single UKI that can be
invoked in one of three ways:
1. The regular profile that just boots the system
2. A profile that boots into storagetm
3. A profile that initiates factory reset and reboots.
For this it would define a classic UKI with sections .linux, .initrd,
.cmdline, and whatever else it needs. The .cmdline section would contain
the kernel command line for the regular profile.
It would then insert one ".profile" section, with a contents like the
following:
ID=regular
This is the profile for profile 0. It would immediately afterwards add
another ".profile" section:
ID=storagetm
TITLE=Boot into Storage Target Mode
This would then followed with a .cmdline section that is just like the
basic one, but with "rd.systemd.unit=storage-target-mode.target"
suffixed. Then, another .profile section would be added:
ID=factory-reset
TITLE=Factory Reset
Which is then followed by one last PE section: a .cmdline one with
"systemd.unit=factory-reset.target" suffixed to te regular command line.
i.e. expressed in tabular form the above would be:
The base profile:
.linux
.initrd
.cmdline
.osrel
The regular boot profile:
.profile
The storagetm profile:
.profile
.cmdline
The factory reset profile:
.profile
.cmdline
You might wonder why the first .cmdline in the list above is placed in
the base profile rather than in the regular boot profile, given that it
is overriden in all other profiles anyway. And you are right. The only
reason I'd place it in the base profile is that it makes the UKI more
nicely extensible if later profiles are added that want to replace
something else instead of the .cmdline, for example .ucode or so. But it
really doesn't matter much.
While the primary usecase is of course multiple alternative command
lines, the concept is more powerful than that: for various usecases it
might be valuable to offer multiple choices of devicetree, ucode or
initrds.
The .profile contents is also passed to the invoked kernel as a file in
/.extra/profile (via a synthetic initrd). Thus, this functionality can
even be useful without overriding any section at all, simply by means of
reading that file from userspace.
Design choices:
1. On purposes I used a special command line marker (i.e. the "@" thing,
which maybe we should call the "profile selector"), that doesn't look
like a regular kernel command line option. This is because this is
really not a regular kernel command line option – we process it in
the stub, then remove it as prefix, and measure the unprefixed
command line only after that. The kernel will not see the profile
selector either. I think these special semantics are best
communicated by making it look substantially different from regular
options.
2. This moves around measurements a bit. Previously we measured our UKI
sections right after finding them. Now we first parse the profile
number from the command line, then search for the profile's sections,
and only then measure the sections we actually end up using for this
profile. I think that this logic makes most sense: measure what we
are using, not what we are overriding. Or in other words, if you boot
profile @3, then we'll measure .cmdline (assuming it exists) of
profile 3, and *not* measure .cmdline of the base profile. Also note
that if the user passes in a custom kernel command line via command
line arguments we'll strip off the profile selector (i.e. the initial
"@X" thing) before we pass it on.
3. The .profile stuff is supposed to be generic and extensible. For
example we could use it in future to mark "dangerous" options such as
factory reset, so that boot menus can ask for confirmation before
booting into it. Or we could introduce match expressions against
SMBIOS or other system identifiers, to filter out profiles on
specific hw.
Note btw, that PE allows defining multiple sections that point to the
same offsets in the file. This allows sharing payload under different
names. For example, if profile @4 and @7 shall carry the same .ucode
section, they can define .ucode in each profile and then make it point to
the same offset.
Also note that that one can even "mask" a base section in a profile, by
inserting an empty section. For example, if the base .dtb section should
not be used for profile @4, then add a section .dtb right after the
fourth .profile with a zero size to the UKI, and you will get your wish
fulfilled.
This code only contains changes to sd-stub. A follow-up commit will
teach sd-boot to also find this profile PE sections to synthesize
additional menu entries from a single UKI.
A later commit will add support for gnerating this via ukify.
Fixes: #24539
2024-06-27 23:21:58 +03:00
<refsect1 >
<title > Multi-Profile UKIs</title>
<para > In many contexts it is useful to allow invocation of a single UKI in multiple different modes (or
"profiles") without compromising the cryptographic integrity, measurements and so on of the boot
process. For example, a single UKI might provide three distinct profiles: a regular boot one, one that
invokes a "factory reset" operation, and one that boots into a storage target mode (as in
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-storagetm.service</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 8</manvolnum> </citerefentry> ). Each
profile would then use the same <literal > .linux</literal> and <literal > .initrd</literal> sections, but would
have a separate <literal > .cmdline</literal> section. For example the latter two profiles would extend the
regular kernel command line with <literal > systemd.unit=factory-reset.target</literal> or
<literal > rd.systemd.unit=storagetm.target</literal> .</para>
<para > A single UKI may support multiple profiles by means of the special <literal > .profile</literal> PE
section. This section acts as separator between the PE sections of the individual
profiles. <literal > .profile</literal> PE sections hence may appear multiple times in a single UKI, and
the other PE sections listed above may appear multiple times too, if <literal > .profile</literal> are
used, but only once before the first <literal > .profile</literal> section, once between each subsequent
pair, and once after the last appearance of <literal > .profile</literal> . The sections listed before the
first <literal > .profile</literal> are considered the "base" profile of the UKI. Each
<literal > .profile</literal> section then introduces a new profile, which are numbered starting from
zero. The PE sections following each <literal > .profile</literal> are specific to that profile. When
booting into a specific profile the base section's profiles are used in combination with the specific
profile's sections: if the same section is defined in both, the per-profile section overrides the base
profile's version, otherwise the per-profile sections is used together with the base profile
sections.</para> <para > A UKI that contains no <literal > .profile</literal> is consider equivalent to one
that just contains a single <literal > .profile</literal> , as having only a single profile @0.</para>
<para > Here's a simple example for a multi-profile UKI's sections, inspired by the setup suggested above:</para>
<table >
<title > Multi-Profile UKI Example</title>
<tgroup cols= '2' align= 'left' colsep= '1' rowsep= '1' >
<colspec colname= "section" />
<colspec colname= "profile" />
<thead >
<row >
<entry > Section</entry>
<entry > Profile</entry>
</row>
</thead>
<tbody >
<row >
<entry > <literal > .linux</literal> </entry>
<entry morerows= "3" valign= "middle" > Base profile</entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > <literal > .osrel</literal> </entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > <literal > .cmdline</literal> </entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > <literal > .initrd</literal> </entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > <literal > .profile</literal> </entry>
<entry > Profile @0</entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > <literal > .profile</literal> </entry>
<entry morerows= "1" valign= "middle" > Profile @1</entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > <literal > .cmdline</literal> </entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > <literal > .profile</literal> </entry>
<entry morerows= "1" valign= "middle" > Profile @2</entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > <literal > .cmdline</literal> </entry>
</row>
</tbody>
</tgroup>
</table>
<para > The section list above would define three profiles. The first four sections make up the base
profile. A <literal > .profile</literal> section then introduces profile @0. It doesn't override any
sections (or add any) from the base section, hence it is immediately followed by another
<literal > .profile</literal> section that then introduces section @1. This profile overrides the kernel
command line. Finally, the last two sections define section @2, again overriding the command line. (Note
that in this example the first <literal > .cmdline</literal> could also moved behind the first
<literal > .profile</literal> with equivalent effect. To keep things nicely extensible, it's probably a
good idea to keep the generic command line in the base section instead of profile 0, in case later added
profiles might want to reuse it.)</para>
<para > The profile to boot may be controlled via the UKI's own command line: if the first argument starts
with <literal > @</literal> , followed by a positive integer number in decimal, it selects the profile to
boot into. If the first argument is not specified like that, the UKI will automatically boot into profile
0.</para>
<para > A <literal > .profile</literal> section may contain meta-information about the profile. It follows a
similar format as <literal > .osrel</literal> (i.e. an environment-variable-assignment-block-like list of
newline separated strings). Currently two fields are defined: <literal > ID=</literal> is supposed to carry
a short identifying string that identifies the profile
(e.g. <literal > ID=factory-reset</literal> ). <literal > TITLE=</literal> should contain a human readable
string that may appear in the boot menu entry for this profile (e.g. <literal > TITLE='Factory Reset this
Device'</literal> ).</para>
</refsect1>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
<refsect1 >
2022-09-09 12:09:30 +03:00
<title > TPM PCR Notes</title>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
<para > Note that when a unified kernel using <command > systemd-stub</command> is invoked the firmware will
measure it as a whole to TPM PCR 4, covering all embedded resources, such as the stub code itself, the
stub: add ability to place multiple alternative PE sections of a specific type in the same UKI ("Multi-Profile UKIs")
This adds a ability to add alternative sections of a specific type in
the same UKI. The primary usecase is for supporting multiple different
kernel cmdlines that are baked into a UKI.
The mechanism is relatively simple (I think), in order to make it robust.
1. A new PE section ".profile" is introduced, that is a lot like
".osrel", but contains information about a specific "profile" to
boot. The ".profile" section can appear multiple times in the same
PE, and acts as delimiter indicating where a new profile starts.
Everything before the first ".profile" is called the "base profile",
and is shared among all other profiles, which can then override or
add addition PE sections on top.
2. An UKI's command line can be prefixed with an argument such as "@0" or
"@1" or "@2" which indicates the "profile" to boot. If no argument is
specified the default is profile 0. Also, a UKI that lacks any
.profile section is treated like one with only a profile 0, but with
no data in that profile section.
3. The stub will first search for its usual set of PE sections
(hereafter called "base sections"), and stop at the first .profile PE
section if any. It will then find the .profile matching the selected
profile by its index, and any sections found as part of that profile
on top of the base sections.
And that's already it.
Example: let's say a distro wants to provide a single UKI that can be
invoked in one of three ways:
1. The regular profile that just boots the system
2. A profile that boots into storagetm
3. A profile that initiates factory reset and reboots.
For this it would define a classic UKI with sections .linux, .initrd,
.cmdline, and whatever else it needs. The .cmdline section would contain
the kernel command line for the regular profile.
It would then insert one ".profile" section, with a contents like the
following:
ID=regular
This is the profile for profile 0. It would immediately afterwards add
another ".profile" section:
ID=storagetm
TITLE=Boot into Storage Target Mode
This would then followed with a .cmdline section that is just like the
basic one, but with "rd.systemd.unit=storage-target-mode.target"
suffixed. Then, another .profile section would be added:
ID=factory-reset
TITLE=Factory Reset
Which is then followed by one last PE section: a .cmdline one with
"systemd.unit=factory-reset.target" suffixed to te regular command line.
i.e. expressed in tabular form the above would be:
The base profile:
.linux
.initrd
.cmdline
.osrel
The regular boot profile:
.profile
The storagetm profile:
.profile
.cmdline
The factory reset profile:
.profile
.cmdline
You might wonder why the first .cmdline in the list above is placed in
the base profile rather than in the regular boot profile, given that it
is overriden in all other profiles anyway. And you are right. The only
reason I'd place it in the base profile is that it makes the UKI more
nicely extensible if later profiles are added that want to replace
something else instead of the .cmdline, for example .ucode or so. But it
really doesn't matter much.
While the primary usecase is of course multiple alternative command
lines, the concept is more powerful than that: for various usecases it
might be valuable to offer multiple choices of devicetree, ucode or
initrds.
The .profile contents is also passed to the invoked kernel as a file in
/.extra/profile (via a synthetic initrd). Thus, this functionality can
even be useful without overriding any section at all, simply by means of
reading that file from userspace.
Design choices:
1. On purposes I used a special command line marker (i.e. the "@" thing,
which maybe we should call the "profile selector"), that doesn't look
like a regular kernel command line option. This is because this is
really not a regular kernel command line option – we process it in
the stub, then remove it as prefix, and measure the unprefixed
command line only after that. The kernel will not see the profile
selector either. I think these special semantics are best
communicated by making it look substantially different from regular
options.
2. This moves around measurements a bit. Previously we measured our UKI
sections right after finding them. Now we first parse the profile
number from the command line, then search for the profile's sections,
and only then measure the sections we actually end up using for this
profile. I think that this logic makes most sense: measure what we
are using, not what we are overriding. Or in other words, if you boot
profile @3, then we'll measure .cmdline (assuming it exists) of
profile 3, and *not* measure .cmdline of the base profile. Also note
that if the user passes in a custom kernel command line via command
line arguments we'll strip off the profile selector (i.e. the initial
"@X" thing) before we pass it on.
3. The .profile stuff is supposed to be generic and extensible. For
example we could use it in future to mark "dangerous" options such as
factory reset, so that boot menus can ask for confirmation before
booting into it. Or we could introduce match expressions against
SMBIOS or other system identifiers, to filter out profiles on
specific hw.
Note btw, that PE allows defining multiple sections that point to the
same offsets in the file. This allows sharing payload under different
names. For example, if profile @4 and @7 shall carry the same .ucode
section, they can define .ucode in each profile and then make it point to
the same offset.
Also note that that one can even "mask" a base section in a profile, by
inserting an empty section. For example, if the base .dtb section should
not be used for profile @4, then add a section .dtb right after the
fourth .profile with a zero size to the UKI, and you will get your wish
fulfilled.
This code only contains changes to sd-stub. A follow-up commit will
teach sd-boot to also find this profile PE sections to synthesize
additional menu entries from a single UKI.
A later commit will add support for gnerating this via ukify.
Fixes: #24539
2024-06-27 23:21:58 +03:00
core kernel, the embedded initrd and kernel command line (see above for a full list), including all UKI
profiles.</para>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
<para > Also note that the Linux kernel will measure all initrds it receives into TPM PCR 9. This means
stub: add ability to place multiple alternative PE sections of a specific type in the same UKI ("Multi-Profile UKIs")
This adds a ability to add alternative sections of a specific type in
the same UKI. The primary usecase is for supporting multiple different
kernel cmdlines that are baked into a UKI.
The mechanism is relatively simple (I think), in order to make it robust.
1. A new PE section ".profile" is introduced, that is a lot like
".osrel", but contains information about a specific "profile" to
boot. The ".profile" section can appear multiple times in the same
PE, and acts as delimiter indicating where a new profile starts.
Everything before the first ".profile" is called the "base profile",
and is shared among all other profiles, which can then override or
add addition PE sections on top.
2. An UKI's command line can be prefixed with an argument such as "@0" or
"@1" or "@2" which indicates the "profile" to boot. If no argument is
specified the default is profile 0. Also, a UKI that lacks any
.profile section is treated like one with only a profile 0, but with
no data in that profile section.
3. The stub will first search for its usual set of PE sections
(hereafter called "base sections"), and stop at the first .profile PE
section if any. It will then find the .profile matching the selected
profile by its index, and any sections found as part of that profile
on top of the base sections.
And that's already it.
Example: let's say a distro wants to provide a single UKI that can be
invoked in one of three ways:
1. The regular profile that just boots the system
2. A profile that boots into storagetm
3. A profile that initiates factory reset and reboots.
For this it would define a classic UKI with sections .linux, .initrd,
.cmdline, and whatever else it needs. The .cmdline section would contain
the kernel command line for the regular profile.
It would then insert one ".profile" section, with a contents like the
following:
ID=regular
This is the profile for profile 0. It would immediately afterwards add
another ".profile" section:
ID=storagetm
TITLE=Boot into Storage Target Mode
This would then followed with a .cmdline section that is just like the
basic one, but with "rd.systemd.unit=storage-target-mode.target"
suffixed. Then, another .profile section would be added:
ID=factory-reset
TITLE=Factory Reset
Which is then followed by one last PE section: a .cmdline one with
"systemd.unit=factory-reset.target" suffixed to te regular command line.
i.e. expressed in tabular form the above would be:
The base profile:
.linux
.initrd
.cmdline
.osrel
The regular boot profile:
.profile
The storagetm profile:
.profile
.cmdline
The factory reset profile:
.profile
.cmdline
You might wonder why the first .cmdline in the list above is placed in
the base profile rather than in the regular boot profile, given that it
is overriden in all other profiles anyway. And you are right. The only
reason I'd place it in the base profile is that it makes the UKI more
nicely extensible if later profiles are added that want to replace
something else instead of the .cmdline, for example .ucode or so. But it
really doesn't matter much.
While the primary usecase is of course multiple alternative command
lines, the concept is more powerful than that: for various usecases it
might be valuable to offer multiple choices of devicetree, ucode or
initrds.
The .profile contents is also passed to the invoked kernel as a file in
/.extra/profile (via a synthetic initrd). Thus, this functionality can
even be useful without overriding any section at all, simply by means of
reading that file from userspace.
Design choices:
1. On purposes I used a special command line marker (i.e. the "@" thing,
which maybe we should call the "profile selector"), that doesn't look
like a regular kernel command line option. This is because this is
really not a regular kernel command line option – we process it in
the stub, then remove it as prefix, and measure the unprefixed
command line only after that. The kernel will not see the profile
selector either. I think these special semantics are best
communicated by making it look substantially different from regular
options.
2. This moves around measurements a bit. Previously we measured our UKI
sections right after finding them. Now we first parse the profile
number from the command line, then search for the profile's sections,
and only then measure the sections we actually end up using for this
profile. I think that this logic makes most sense: measure what we
are using, not what we are overriding. Or in other words, if you boot
profile @3, then we'll measure .cmdline (assuming it exists) of
profile 3, and *not* measure .cmdline of the base profile. Also note
that if the user passes in a custom kernel command line via command
line arguments we'll strip off the profile selector (i.e. the initial
"@X" thing) before we pass it on.
3. The .profile stuff is supposed to be generic and extensible. For
example we could use it in future to mark "dangerous" options such as
factory reset, so that boot menus can ask for confirmation before
booting into it. Or we could introduce match expressions against
SMBIOS or other system identifiers, to filter out profiles on
specific hw.
Note btw, that PE allows defining multiple sections that point to the
same offsets in the file. This allows sharing payload under different
names. For example, if profile @4 and @7 shall carry the same .ucode
section, they can define .ucode in each profile and then make it point to
the same offset.
Also note that that one can even "mask" a base section in a profile, by
inserting an empty section. For example, if the base .dtb section should
not be used for profile @4, then add a section .dtb right after the
fourth .profile with a zero size to the UKI, and you will get your wish
fulfilled.
This code only contains changes to sd-stub. A follow-up commit will
teach sd-boot to also find this profile PE sections to synthesize
additional menu entries from a single UKI.
A later commit will add support for gnerating this via ukify.
Fixes: #24539
2024-06-27 23:21:58 +03:00
every type of initrd (of the selected UKI profile) will possibly be measured two or three times: the
initrds embedded in the kernel image will be measured to PCR 4, PCR 9 and PCR 11; the initrd synthesized
from credentials (and the one synthesized from configuration extensions) will be measured to both PCR 9
and PCR 12; the initrd synthesized from system extensions will be measured to both PCR 4 and PCR 9. Let's
summarize the OS resources and the PCRs they are measured to:</para>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
<table >
<title > OS Resource PCR Summary</title>
<tgroup cols= '2' align= 'left' colsep= '1' rowsep= '1' >
<colspec colname= "pcr" />
<colspec colname= "definition" />
<thead >
<row >
<entry > OS Resource</entry>
<entry > Measurement PCR</entry>
</row>
</thead>
<tbody >
<row >
<entry > <command > systemd-stub</command> code (the entry point of the unified PE binary)</entry>
<entry > 4</entry>
</row>
<row >
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
<entry > Core kernel code (embedded in unified PE binary)</entry>
efi: from the stub measure the ELF kernel + built-in initrd and so on into PCR 11
Here we grab a new – on Linux so far unused (by my Googling skills, that
is) – and measure all static components of the PE kernel image into.
This is useful since for the first time we'll have a PCR that contains
only a PCR of the booted kernel, nothing else. That allows putting
together TPM policies that bind to a specific kernel (+ builtin initrd),
without having to have booted that kernel first. PCRs can be
pre-calculated. Yay!
You might wonder, why we measure just the discovered PE sections we are
about to use, instead of the whole PE image. That's because of the next
step I have in mind: PE images should also be able to carry an
additional section that contains a signature for its own expected,
pre-calculated PCR values. This signature data should then be passed
into the booted kernel and can be used there in TPM policies. Benefit:
TPM policies can now be bound to *signatures* of PCRs, instead of the
raw hash values themselves. This makes update management a *lot* easier,
as policies don't need to be updated whenever a kernel is updated, as
long as the signature is available. Now, if the PCR signature is
embedded in the kernel PE image it cannot be of a PCR hash of the kernel
PE image itself, because that would be a chicken-and-egg problem. Hence,
by only measuring the relavent payload sections (and that means
excluding the future section that will contain the PCR hash signature)
we avoid this problem, naturally.
2022-07-25 18:44:24 +03:00
<entry > 4 + 11</entry>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
</row>
<row >
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
<entry > OS release information (embedded in the unified PE binary)</entry>
efi: from the stub measure the ELF kernel + built-in initrd and so on into PCR 11
Here we grab a new – on Linux so far unused (by my Googling skills, that
is) – and measure all static components of the PE kernel image into.
This is useful since for the first time we'll have a PCR that contains
only a PCR of the booted kernel, nothing else. That allows putting
together TPM policies that bind to a specific kernel (+ builtin initrd),
without having to have booted that kernel first. PCRs can be
pre-calculated. Yay!
You might wonder, why we measure just the discovered PE sections we are
about to use, instead of the whole PE image. That's because of the next
step I have in mind: PE images should also be able to carry an
additional section that contains a signature for its own expected,
pre-calculated PCR values. This signature data should then be passed
into the booted kernel and can be used there in TPM policies. Benefit:
TPM policies can now be bound to *signatures* of PCRs, instead of the
raw hash values themselves. This makes update management a *lot* easier,
as policies don't need to be updated whenever a kernel is updated, as
long as the signature is available. Now, if the PCR signature is
embedded in the kernel PE image it cannot be of a PCR hash of the kernel
PE image itself, because that would be a chicken-and-egg problem. Hence,
by only measuring the relavent payload sections (and that means
excluding the future section that will contain the PCR hash signature)
we avoid this problem, naturally.
2022-07-25 18:44:24 +03:00
<entry > 4 + 11</entry>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
</row>
<row >
<entry > Main initrd (embedded in unified PE binary)</entry>
efi: from the stub measure the ELF kernel + built-in initrd and so on into PCR 11
Here we grab a new – on Linux so far unused (by my Googling skills, that
is) – and measure all static components of the PE kernel image into.
This is useful since for the first time we'll have a PCR that contains
only a PCR of the booted kernel, nothing else. That allows putting
together TPM policies that bind to a specific kernel (+ builtin initrd),
without having to have booted that kernel first. PCRs can be
pre-calculated. Yay!
You might wonder, why we measure just the discovered PE sections we are
about to use, instead of the whole PE image. That's because of the next
step I have in mind: PE images should also be able to carry an
additional section that contains a signature for its own expected,
pre-calculated PCR values. This signature data should then be passed
into the booted kernel and can be used there in TPM policies. Benefit:
TPM policies can now be bound to *signatures* of PCRs, instead of the
raw hash values themselves. This makes update management a *lot* easier,
as policies don't need to be updated whenever a kernel is updated, as
long as the signature is available. Now, if the PCR signature is
embedded in the kernel PE image it cannot be of a PCR hash of the kernel
PE image itself, because that would be a chicken-and-egg problem. Hence,
by only measuring the relavent payload sections (and that means
excluding the future section that will contain the PCR hash signature)
we avoid this problem, naturally.
2022-07-25 18:44:24 +03:00
<entry > 4 + 9 + 11</entry>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
</row>
2024-04-02 13:54:30 +03:00
<row >
<entry > Microcode initrd (embedded in unified PE binary)</entry>
<entry > 4 + 9 + 11</entry>
</row>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
<row >
<entry > Default kernel command line (embedded in unified PE binary)</entry>
efi: from the stub measure the ELF kernel + built-in initrd and so on into PCR 11
Here we grab a new – on Linux so far unused (by my Googling skills, that
is) – and measure all static components of the PE kernel image into.
This is useful since for the first time we'll have a PCR that contains
only a PCR of the booted kernel, nothing else. That allows putting
together TPM policies that bind to a specific kernel (+ builtin initrd),
without having to have booted that kernel first. PCRs can be
pre-calculated. Yay!
You might wonder, why we measure just the discovered PE sections we are
about to use, instead of the whole PE image. That's because of the next
step I have in mind: PE images should also be able to carry an
additional section that contains a signature for its own expected,
pre-calculated PCR values. This signature data should then be passed
into the booted kernel and can be used there in TPM policies. Benefit:
TPM policies can now be bound to *signatures* of PCRs, instead of the
raw hash values themselves. This makes update management a *lot* easier,
as policies don't need to be updated whenever a kernel is updated, as
long as the signature is available. Now, if the PCR signature is
embedded in the kernel PE image it cannot be of a PCR hash of the kernel
PE image itself, because that would be a chicken-and-egg problem. Hence,
by only measuring the relavent payload sections (and that means
excluding the future section that will contain the PCR hash signature)
we avoid this problem, naturally.
2022-07-25 18:44:24 +03:00
<entry > 4 + 11</entry>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
</row>
<row >
2022-04-25 04:06:08 +03:00
<entry > Overridden kernel command line</entry>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
<entry > 12</entry>
</row>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
<row >
<entry > Boot splash (embedded in the unified PE binary)</entry>
<entry > 4 + 11</entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > TPM2 PCR signature JSON (embedded in unified PE binary, synthesized into initrd)</entry>
<entry > 4 + 9</entry>
</row>
<row >
<entry > TPM2 PCR PEM public key (embedded in unified PE binary, synthesized into initrd)</entry>
<entry > 4 + 9 + 11</entry>
</row>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
<row >
<entry > Credentials (synthesized initrd from companion files)</entry>
2022-07-26 19:32:21 +03:00
<entry > 9 + 12</entry>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
</row>
<row >
<entry > System Extensions (synthesized initrd from companion files)</entry>
sd-stub: measure sysext images picked up by sd-stub into PCR 13
Let's grab another so far unused PCR, and measure all sysext images into
it that we load from the ESP. Note that this is possibly partly redundant,
since sysext images should have dm-verity enabled, and that is hooked up
to IMA. However, measuring this explicitly has the benefit that we can
measure filenames too, easily, and that all without need for IMA or
anything like that.
This means: when booting a unified sd-stub kernel through sd-boot we'll
now have:
1. PCR 11: unified kernel image payload (i.e. kernel, initrd, boot
splash, dtb, osrelease)
2. PCR 12: kernel command line (i.e. the one embedded in the image, plus
optionally an overriden one) + any credential files picked up by
sd-stub
3. PCR 13: sysext images picked up by sd-stub
And each of these three PCRs should carry just the above, and start from
zero, thus be pre-calculatable.
Thus, all components and parameters of the OS boot process (i.e.
everything after the boot loader) is now nicely pre-calculable.
NOTE: this actually replaces previous measuring of the syext images into
PCR 4. I added this back in 845707aae23b3129db635604edb95c4048a5922a,
following the train of thought, that sysext images for the initrd should
be measured like the initrd itself they are for, and according to my
thinking that would be a unified kernel which is measured by firmware
into PCR 4 like any other UEFI executables.
However, I think we should depart from that idea. First and foremost
that makes it harder to pre-calculate PCR 4 (since we actually measured
quite incompatible records to the TPM event log), but also I think
there's great value in being able to write policies that bind to the
used sysexts independently of the earlier boot chain (i.e. shim, boot
loader, unified kernel), hence a separate PCR makes more sense.
Strictly speaking, this is a compatibility break, but I think one we can
get away with, simply because the initrd sysext images are currently not
picked up by systemd-sysext yet in the initrd, and because of that we
can be reasonably sure noone uses this yet, and hence relies on the PCR
register used. Hence, let's clean this up before people actually do
start relying on this.
2022-07-26 12:35:57 +03:00
<entry > 9 + 13</entry>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
</row>
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
<row >
<entry > Configuration Extensions (synthesized initrd from companion files)</entry>
<entry > 9 + 12</entry>
</row>
stub: add ability to place multiple alternative PE sections of a specific type in the same UKI ("Multi-Profile UKIs")
This adds a ability to add alternative sections of a specific type in
the same UKI. The primary usecase is for supporting multiple different
kernel cmdlines that are baked into a UKI.
The mechanism is relatively simple (I think), in order to make it robust.
1. A new PE section ".profile" is introduced, that is a lot like
".osrel", but contains information about a specific "profile" to
boot. The ".profile" section can appear multiple times in the same
PE, and acts as delimiter indicating where a new profile starts.
Everything before the first ".profile" is called the "base profile",
and is shared among all other profiles, which can then override or
add addition PE sections on top.
2. An UKI's command line can be prefixed with an argument such as "@0" or
"@1" or "@2" which indicates the "profile" to boot. If no argument is
specified the default is profile 0. Also, a UKI that lacks any
.profile section is treated like one with only a profile 0, but with
no data in that profile section.
3. The stub will first search for its usual set of PE sections
(hereafter called "base sections"), and stop at the first .profile PE
section if any. It will then find the .profile matching the selected
profile by its index, and any sections found as part of that profile
on top of the base sections.
And that's already it.
Example: let's say a distro wants to provide a single UKI that can be
invoked in one of three ways:
1. The regular profile that just boots the system
2. A profile that boots into storagetm
3. A profile that initiates factory reset and reboots.
For this it would define a classic UKI with sections .linux, .initrd,
.cmdline, and whatever else it needs. The .cmdline section would contain
the kernel command line for the regular profile.
It would then insert one ".profile" section, with a contents like the
following:
ID=regular
This is the profile for profile 0. It would immediately afterwards add
another ".profile" section:
ID=storagetm
TITLE=Boot into Storage Target Mode
This would then followed with a .cmdline section that is just like the
basic one, but with "rd.systemd.unit=storage-target-mode.target"
suffixed. Then, another .profile section would be added:
ID=factory-reset
TITLE=Factory Reset
Which is then followed by one last PE section: a .cmdline one with
"systemd.unit=factory-reset.target" suffixed to te regular command line.
i.e. expressed in tabular form the above would be:
The base profile:
.linux
.initrd
.cmdline
.osrel
The regular boot profile:
.profile
The storagetm profile:
.profile
.cmdline
The factory reset profile:
.profile
.cmdline
You might wonder why the first .cmdline in the list above is placed in
the base profile rather than in the regular boot profile, given that it
is overriden in all other profiles anyway. And you are right. The only
reason I'd place it in the base profile is that it makes the UKI more
nicely extensible if later profiles are added that want to replace
something else instead of the .cmdline, for example .ucode or so. But it
really doesn't matter much.
While the primary usecase is of course multiple alternative command
lines, the concept is more powerful than that: for various usecases it
might be valuable to offer multiple choices of devicetree, ucode or
initrds.
The .profile contents is also passed to the invoked kernel as a file in
/.extra/profile (via a synthetic initrd). Thus, this functionality can
even be useful without overriding any section at all, simply by means of
reading that file from userspace.
Design choices:
1. On purposes I used a special command line marker (i.e. the "@" thing,
which maybe we should call the "profile selector"), that doesn't look
like a regular kernel command line option. This is because this is
really not a regular kernel command line option – we process it in
the stub, then remove it as prefix, and measure the unprefixed
command line only after that. The kernel will not see the profile
selector either. I think these special semantics are best
communicated by making it look substantially different from regular
options.
2. This moves around measurements a bit. Previously we measured our UKI
sections right after finding them. Now we first parse the profile
number from the command line, then search for the profile's sections,
and only then measure the sections we actually end up using for this
profile. I think that this logic makes most sense: measure what we
are using, not what we are overriding. Or in other words, if you boot
profile @3, then we'll measure .cmdline (assuming it exists) of
profile 3, and *not* measure .cmdline of the base profile. Also note
that if the user passes in a custom kernel command line via command
line arguments we'll strip off the profile selector (i.e. the initial
"@X" thing) before we pass it on.
3. The .profile stuff is supposed to be generic and extensible. For
example we could use it in future to mark "dangerous" options such as
factory reset, so that boot menus can ask for confirmation before
booting into it. Or we could introduce match expressions against
SMBIOS or other system identifiers, to filter out profiles on
specific hw.
Note btw, that PE allows defining multiple sections that point to the
same offsets in the file. This allows sharing payload under different
names. For example, if profile @4 and @7 shall carry the same .ucode
section, they can define .ucode in each profile and then make it point to
the same offset.
Also note that that one can even "mask" a base section in a profile, by
inserting an empty section. For example, if the base .dtb section should
not be used for profile @4, then add a section .dtb right after the
fourth .profile with a zero size to the UKI, and you will get your wish
fulfilled.
This code only contains changes to sd-stub. A follow-up commit will
teach sd-boot to also find this profile PE sections to synthesize
additional menu entries from a single UKI.
A later commit will add support for gnerating this via ukify.
Fixes: #24539
2024-06-27 23:21:58 +03:00
<row >
<entry > Selected profile unless zero</entry>
<entry > 12</entry>
</row>
2022-04-14 15:38:52 +03:00
</tbody>
</tgroup>
</table>
</refsect1>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<refsect1 >
<title > EFI Variables</title>
<para > The following EFI variables are defined, set and read by <command > systemd-stub</command> , under the
vendor UUID <literal > 4a67b082-0a4c-41cf-b6c7-440b29bb8c4f</literal> , for communication between the boot
stub and the OS:</para>
<variablelist class= 'efi-variables' >
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > LoaderDevicePartUUID</varname> </term>
2024-07-15 17:06:40 +03:00
<listitem > <para > Contains the partition UUID of the partition the boot loader has been started from on
the current boot (usually a EFI System Partition). If already set by the boot loader, this will
remain untouched by <command > systemd-stub</command> . If not set yet, this will be set to the
partition UUID of the partition the unified kernel is started from, in order to support systems that
directly boot into a unified kernel image, bypassing any boot loader.
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-gpt-auto-generator</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 8</manvolnum> </citerefentry>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
uses this information to automatically find the disk booted from, in order to discover various other
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
partitions on the same disk automatically.</para>
2024-07-15 17:06:40 +03:00
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v224" /> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</varlistentry>
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > LoaderFirmwareInfo</varname> </term>
<term > <varname > LoaderFirmwareType</varname> </term>
<listitem > <para > Brief firmware information. Use
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > bootctl</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> to view this
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
data.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v250" /> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</varlistentry>
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > LoaderImageIdentifier</varname> </term>
2024-07-15 17:06:40 +03:00
<listitem > <para > The file system path to the EFI executable of the boot loader for the current boot,
relative to the partition's root directory (i.e. relative to the partition indicated by
<varname > LoaderDevicePartUUID</varname> , see above). If not set yet, this will be set to the file
system path of the EFI executable of the booted unified kernel, in order to support systems that
directly boot into a unified kernel image, bypassing any boot loader. Use
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > bootctl</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> to view
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
this data.</para>
2024-07-15 17:06:40 +03:00
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v237" /> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</varlistentry>
2024-07-15 17:11:31 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > StubDevicePartUUID</varname> </term>
<term > <varname > StubImageIdentifier</varname> </term>
<listitem > <para > Similar to <varname > LoaderDevicePartUUID</varname> and
<varname > StubImageIdentifier</varname> , but indicates the location of the unified kernel image EFI
binary rather than the location of the boot loader binary, regardless if booted via a boot loader
or not.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v257" /> </listitem>
</varlistentry>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > StubInfo</varname> </term>
<listitem > <para > Brief stub information. Use
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > bootctl</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> to view
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
this data.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v250" /> </listitem>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</varlistentry>
2022-07-26 19:32:21 +03:00
efi: from the stub measure the ELF kernel + built-in initrd and so on into PCR 11
Here we grab a new – on Linux so far unused (by my Googling skills, that
is) – and measure all static components of the PE kernel image into.
This is useful since for the first time we'll have a PCR that contains
only a PCR of the booted kernel, nothing else. That allows putting
together TPM policies that bind to a specific kernel (+ builtin initrd),
without having to have booted that kernel first. PCRs can be
pre-calculated. Yay!
You might wonder, why we measure just the discovered PE sections we are
about to use, instead of the whole PE image. That's because of the next
step I have in mind: PE images should also be able to carry an
additional section that contains a signature for its own expected,
pre-calculated PCR values. This signature data should then be passed
into the booted kernel and can be used there in TPM policies. Benefit:
TPM policies can now be bound to *signatures* of PCRs, instead of the
raw hash values themselves. This makes update management a *lot* easier,
as policies don't need to be updated whenever a kernel is updated, as
long as the signature is available. Now, if the PCR signature is
embedded in the kernel PE image it cannot be of a PCR hash of the kernel
PE image itself, because that would be a chicken-and-egg problem. Hence,
by only measuring the relavent payload sections (and that means
excluding the future section that will contain the PCR hash signature)
we avoid this problem, naturally.
2022-07-25 18:44:24 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > StubPcrKernelImage</varname> </term>
man: "the initial RAM disk" → "the initrd"
In many places we spelled out the phrase behind "initrd" in full, but this
isn't terribly useful. In fact, no "RAM disk" is used, so emphasizing this
is just confusing to the reader. Let's just say "initrd" everywhere, people
understand what this refers to, and that it's in fact an initramfs image.
Also, s/i.e./e.g./ where appropriate.
Also, don't say "in RAM", when in fact it's virtual memory, whose pages
may or may not be loaded in page frames in RAM, and we have no control over
this.
Also, add <filename></filename> and other minor cleanups.
2022-09-15 15:43:59 +03:00
<listitem > <para > The PCR register index the kernel image, initrd image, boot splash, devicetree
database, and the embedded command line are measured into, formatted as decimal ASCII string (e.g.
<literal > 11</literal> ). This variable is set if a measurement was successfully completed, and remains
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
unset otherwise.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
efi: from the stub measure the ELF kernel + built-in initrd and so on into PCR 11
Here we grab a new – on Linux so far unused (by my Googling skills, that
is) – and measure all static components of the PE kernel image into.
This is useful since for the first time we'll have a PCR that contains
only a PCR of the booted kernel, nothing else. That allows putting
together TPM policies that bind to a specific kernel (+ builtin initrd),
without having to have booted that kernel first. PCRs can be
pre-calculated. Yay!
You might wonder, why we measure just the discovered PE sections we are
about to use, instead of the whole PE image. That's because of the next
step I have in mind: PE images should also be able to carry an
additional section that contains a signature for its own expected,
pre-calculated PCR values. This signature data should then be passed
into the booted kernel and can be used there in TPM policies. Benefit:
TPM policies can now be bound to *signatures* of PCRs, instead of the
raw hash values themselves. This makes update management a *lot* easier,
as policies don't need to be updated whenever a kernel is updated, as
long as the signature is available. Now, if the PCR signature is
embedded in the kernel PE image it cannot be of a PCR hash of the kernel
PE image itself, because that would be a chicken-and-egg problem. Hence,
by only measuring the relavent payload sections (and that means
excluding the future section that will contain the PCR hash signature)
we avoid this problem, naturally.
2022-07-25 18:44:24 +03:00
</varlistentry>
2022-07-26 19:32:21 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > StubPcrKernelParameters</varname> </term>
<listitem > <para > The PCR register index the kernel command line and credentials are measured into,
man: "the initial RAM disk" → "the initrd"
In many places we spelled out the phrase behind "initrd" in full, but this
isn't terribly useful. In fact, no "RAM disk" is used, so emphasizing this
is just confusing to the reader. Let's just say "initrd" everywhere, people
understand what this refers to, and that it's in fact an initramfs image.
Also, s/i.e./e.g./ where appropriate.
Also, don't say "in RAM", when in fact it's virtual memory, whose pages
may or may not be loaded in page frames in RAM, and we have no control over
this.
Also, add <filename></filename> and other minor cleanups.
2022-09-15 15:43:59 +03:00
formatted as decimal ASCII string (e.g. <literal > 12</literal> ). This variable is set if a measurement
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
was successfully completed, and remains unset otherwise.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
2022-07-26 19:32:21 +03:00
</varlistentry>
sd-stub: measure sysext images picked up by sd-stub into PCR 13
Let's grab another so far unused PCR, and measure all sysext images into
it that we load from the ESP. Note that this is possibly partly redundant,
since sysext images should have dm-verity enabled, and that is hooked up
to IMA. However, measuring this explicitly has the benefit that we can
measure filenames too, easily, and that all without need for IMA or
anything like that.
This means: when booting a unified sd-stub kernel through sd-boot we'll
now have:
1. PCR 11: unified kernel image payload (i.e. kernel, initrd, boot
splash, dtb, osrelease)
2. PCR 12: kernel command line (i.e. the one embedded in the image, plus
optionally an overriden one) + any credential files picked up by
sd-stub
3. PCR 13: sysext images picked up by sd-stub
And each of these three PCRs should carry just the above, and start from
zero, thus be pre-calculatable.
Thus, all components and parameters of the OS boot process (i.e.
everything after the boot loader) is now nicely pre-calculable.
NOTE: this actually replaces previous measuring of the syext images into
PCR 4. I added this back in 845707aae23b3129db635604edb95c4048a5922a,
following the train of thought, that sysext images for the initrd should
be measured like the initrd itself they are for, and according to my
thinking that would be a unified kernel which is measured by firmware
into PCR 4 like any other UEFI executables.
However, I think we should depart from that idea. First and foremost
that makes it harder to pre-calculate PCR 4 (since we actually measured
quite incompatible records to the TPM event log), but also I think
there's great value in being able to write policies that bind to the
used sysexts independently of the earlier boot chain (i.e. shim, boot
loader, unified kernel), hence a separate PCR makes more sense.
Strictly speaking, this is a compatibility break, but I think one we can
get away with, simply because the initrd sysext images are currently not
picked up by systemd-sysext yet in the initrd, and because of that we
can be reasonably sure noone uses this yet, and hence relies on the PCR
register used. Hence, let's clean this up before people actually do
start relying on this.
2022-07-26 12:35:57 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > StubPcrInitRDSysExts</varname> </term>
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
<listitem > <para > The PCR register index the system extensions for the initrd, which are picked up from
the file system the kernel image is located on. Formatted as decimal ASCII string (e.g.
man: "the initial RAM disk" → "the initrd"
In many places we spelled out the phrase behind "initrd" in full, but this
isn't terribly useful. In fact, no "RAM disk" is used, so emphasizing this
is just confusing to the reader. Let's just say "initrd" everywhere, people
understand what this refers to, and that it's in fact an initramfs image.
Also, s/i.e./e.g./ where appropriate.
Also, don't say "in RAM", when in fact it's virtual memory, whose pages
may or may not be loaded in page frames in RAM, and we have no control over
this.
Also, add <filename></filename> and other minor cleanups.
2022-09-15 15:43:59 +03:00
<literal > 13</literal> ). This variable is set if a measurement was successfully completed, and remains
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
unset otherwise.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
sd-stub: measure sysext images picked up by sd-stub into PCR 13
Let's grab another so far unused PCR, and measure all sysext images into
it that we load from the ESP. Note that this is possibly partly redundant,
since sysext images should have dm-verity enabled, and that is hooked up
to IMA. However, measuring this explicitly has the benefit that we can
measure filenames too, easily, and that all without need for IMA or
anything like that.
This means: when booting a unified sd-stub kernel through sd-boot we'll
now have:
1. PCR 11: unified kernel image payload (i.e. kernel, initrd, boot
splash, dtb, osrelease)
2. PCR 12: kernel command line (i.e. the one embedded in the image, plus
optionally an overriden one) + any credential files picked up by
sd-stub
3. PCR 13: sysext images picked up by sd-stub
And each of these three PCRs should carry just the above, and start from
zero, thus be pre-calculatable.
Thus, all components and parameters of the OS boot process (i.e.
everything after the boot loader) is now nicely pre-calculable.
NOTE: this actually replaces previous measuring of the syext images into
PCR 4. I added this back in 845707aae23b3129db635604edb95c4048a5922a,
following the train of thought, that sysext images for the initrd should
be measured like the initrd itself they are for, and according to my
thinking that would be a unified kernel which is measured by firmware
into PCR 4 like any other UEFI executables.
However, I think we should depart from that idea. First and foremost
that makes it harder to pre-calculate PCR 4 (since we actually measured
quite incompatible records to the TPM event log), but also I think
there's great value in being able to write policies that bind to the
used sysexts independently of the earlier boot chain (i.e. shim, boot
loader, unified kernel), hence a separate PCR makes more sense.
Strictly speaking, this is a compatibility break, but I think one we can
get away with, simply because the initrd sysext images are currently not
picked up by systemd-sysext yet in the initrd, and because of that we
can be reasonably sure noone uses this yet, and hence relies on the PCR
register used. Hence, let's clean this up before people actually do
start relying on this.
2022-07-26 12:35:57 +03:00
</varlistentry>
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > StubPcrInitRDConfExts</varname> </term>
<listitem > <para > The PCR register index the configuration extensions for the initrd, which are picked
up from the file system the kernel image is located on. Formatted as decimal ASCII string (e.g.
<literal > 12</literal> ). This variable is set if a measurement was successfully completed, and remains
unset otherwise.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v255" /> </listitem>
</varlistentry>
stub: add ability to place multiple alternative PE sections of a specific type in the same UKI ("Multi-Profile UKIs")
This adds a ability to add alternative sections of a specific type in
the same UKI. The primary usecase is for supporting multiple different
kernel cmdlines that are baked into a UKI.
The mechanism is relatively simple (I think), in order to make it robust.
1. A new PE section ".profile" is introduced, that is a lot like
".osrel", but contains information about a specific "profile" to
boot. The ".profile" section can appear multiple times in the same
PE, and acts as delimiter indicating where a new profile starts.
Everything before the first ".profile" is called the "base profile",
and is shared among all other profiles, which can then override or
add addition PE sections on top.
2. An UKI's command line can be prefixed with an argument such as "@0" or
"@1" or "@2" which indicates the "profile" to boot. If no argument is
specified the default is profile 0. Also, a UKI that lacks any
.profile section is treated like one with only a profile 0, but with
no data in that profile section.
3. The stub will first search for its usual set of PE sections
(hereafter called "base sections"), and stop at the first .profile PE
section if any. It will then find the .profile matching the selected
profile by its index, and any sections found as part of that profile
on top of the base sections.
And that's already it.
Example: let's say a distro wants to provide a single UKI that can be
invoked in one of three ways:
1. The regular profile that just boots the system
2. A profile that boots into storagetm
3. A profile that initiates factory reset and reboots.
For this it would define a classic UKI with sections .linux, .initrd,
.cmdline, and whatever else it needs. The .cmdline section would contain
the kernel command line for the regular profile.
It would then insert one ".profile" section, with a contents like the
following:
ID=regular
This is the profile for profile 0. It would immediately afterwards add
another ".profile" section:
ID=storagetm
TITLE=Boot into Storage Target Mode
This would then followed with a .cmdline section that is just like the
basic one, but with "rd.systemd.unit=storage-target-mode.target"
suffixed. Then, another .profile section would be added:
ID=factory-reset
TITLE=Factory Reset
Which is then followed by one last PE section: a .cmdline one with
"systemd.unit=factory-reset.target" suffixed to te regular command line.
i.e. expressed in tabular form the above would be:
The base profile:
.linux
.initrd
.cmdline
.osrel
The regular boot profile:
.profile
The storagetm profile:
.profile
.cmdline
The factory reset profile:
.profile
.cmdline
You might wonder why the first .cmdline in the list above is placed in
the base profile rather than in the regular boot profile, given that it
is overriden in all other profiles anyway. And you are right. The only
reason I'd place it in the base profile is that it makes the UKI more
nicely extensible if later profiles are added that want to replace
something else instead of the .cmdline, for example .ucode or so. But it
really doesn't matter much.
While the primary usecase is of course multiple alternative command
lines, the concept is more powerful than that: for various usecases it
might be valuable to offer multiple choices of devicetree, ucode or
initrds.
The .profile contents is also passed to the invoked kernel as a file in
/.extra/profile (via a synthetic initrd). Thus, this functionality can
even be useful without overriding any section at all, simply by means of
reading that file from userspace.
Design choices:
1. On purposes I used a special command line marker (i.e. the "@" thing,
which maybe we should call the "profile selector"), that doesn't look
like a regular kernel command line option. This is because this is
really not a regular kernel command line option – we process it in
the stub, then remove it as prefix, and measure the unprefixed
command line only after that. The kernel will not see the profile
selector either. I think these special semantics are best
communicated by making it look substantially different from regular
options.
2. This moves around measurements a bit. Previously we measured our UKI
sections right after finding them. Now we first parse the profile
number from the command line, then search for the profile's sections,
and only then measure the sections we actually end up using for this
profile. I think that this logic makes most sense: measure what we
are using, not what we are overriding. Or in other words, if you boot
profile @3, then we'll measure .cmdline (assuming it exists) of
profile 3, and *not* measure .cmdline of the base profile. Also note
that if the user passes in a custom kernel command line via command
line arguments we'll strip off the profile selector (i.e. the initial
"@X" thing) before we pass it on.
3. The .profile stuff is supposed to be generic and extensible. For
example we could use it in future to mark "dangerous" options such as
factory reset, so that boot menus can ask for confirmation before
booting into it. Or we could introduce match expressions against
SMBIOS or other system identifiers, to filter out profiles on
specific hw.
Note btw, that PE allows defining multiple sections that point to the
same offsets in the file. This allows sharing payload under different
names. For example, if profile @4 and @7 shall carry the same .ucode
section, they can define .ucode in each profile and then make it point to
the same offset.
Also note that that one can even "mask" a base section in a profile, by
inserting an empty section. For example, if the base .dtb section should
not be used for profile @4, then add a section .dtb right after the
fourth .profile with a zero size to the UKI, and you will get your wish
fulfilled.
This code only contains changes to sd-stub. A follow-up commit will
teach sd-boot to also find this profile PE sections to synthesize
additional menu entries from a single UKI.
A later commit will add support for gnerating this via ukify.
Fixes: #24539
2024-06-27 23:21:58 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > StubProfile</varname> </term>
<listitem > <para > The numeric index of the selected profile, without the <literal > @</literal> ,
formatted as decimal string. Set both on single-profile and multi-profile UKIs. (In the former case
this variable will be set to <literal > 0</literal> unconditionally.)</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v257" /> </listitem>
</varlistentry>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</variablelist>
<para > Note that some of the variables above may also be set by the boot loader. The stub will only set
them if they aren't set already. Some of these variables are defined by the <ulink
url="https://systemd.io/BOOT_LOADER_INTERFACE">Boot Loader Interface</ulink> .</para>
</refsect1>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
<refsect1 >
<title > initrd Resources</title>
<para > The following resources are passed as initrd cpio archives to the booted kernel, and thus make up
the initial file system hierarchy in the initrd execution environment:</para>
<variablelist >
<varlistentry >
<term > <filename > /</filename> </term>
2023-11-24 17:19:50 +03:00
<listitem > <para > The main initrd from the <literal > .initrd</literal> PE section of the unified kernel
image.</para>
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
</varlistentry>
<varlistentry >
<term > <filename > /.extra/credentials/*.cred</filename> </term>
<listitem > <para > Credential files (suffix <literal > .cred</literal> ) that are placed next to the
unified kernel image (as described above) are copied into the
<filename > /.extra/credentials/</filename> directory in the initrd execution
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
environment.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
</varlistentry>
<varlistentry >
<term > <filename > /.extra/global_credentials/*.cred</filename> </term>
2023-11-24 17:19:50 +03:00
<listitem > <para > Similarly, credential files in the <filename > /loader/credentials/</filename>
directory in the file system the unified kernel image is placed in are copied into the
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
<filename > /.extra/global_credentials/</filename> directory in the initrd execution
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
environment.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
</varlistentry>
<varlistentry >
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
<term > <filename > /.extra/sysext/*.sysext.raw</filename> </term>
<listitem > <para > System extension image files (suffix <literal > .sysext.raw</literal> ) that are placed
next to the unified kernel image (as described above) are copied into the
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
<filename > /.extra/sysext/</filename> directory in the initrd execution environment.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
</varlistentry>
2023-11-08 21:02:03 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <filename > /.extra/confext/*.confext.raw</filename> </term>
<listitem > <para > Configuration extension image files (suffix <literal > .confext.raw</literal> ) that are
placed next to the unified kernel image (as described above) are copied into the
<filename > /.extra/confext/</filename> directory in the initrd execution environment.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v255" /> </listitem>
</varlistentry>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <filename > /.extra/tpm2-pcr-signature.json</filename> </term>
<listitem > <para > The TPM2 PCR signature JSON object included in the <literal > .pcrsig</literal> PE
section of the unified kernel image is copied into the
2023-11-24 17:19:50 +03:00
<filename > /.extra/tpm2-pcr-signature.json</filename> file in the initrd execution environment.</para>
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
</varlistentry>
<varlistentry >
2024-09-12 10:31:29 +03:00
<term > <filename > /.extra/tpm2-pcr-public-key.pem</filename> </term>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
<listitem > <para > The PEM public key included in the <literal > .pcrpkey</literal> PE section of the
unified kernel image is copied into the <filename > /.extra/tpm2-pcr-public-key.pem</filename> file in
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
the initrd execution environment.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v252" /> </listitem>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
</varlistentry>
stub: add ability to place multiple alternative PE sections of a specific type in the same UKI ("Multi-Profile UKIs")
This adds a ability to add alternative sections of a specific type in
the same UKI. The primary usecase is for supporting multiple different
kernel cmdlines that are baked into a UKI.
The mechanism is relatively simple (I think), in order to make it robust.
1. A new PE section ".profile" is introduced, that is a lot like
".osrel", but contains information about a specific "profile" to
boot. The ".profile" section can appear multiple times in the same
PE, and acts as delimiter indicating where a new profile starts.
Everything before the first ".profile" is called the "base profile",
and is shared among all other profiles, which can then override or
add addition PE sections on top.
2. An UKI's command line can be prefixed with an argument such as "@0" or
"@1" or "@2" which indicates the "profile" to boot. If no argument is
specified the default is profile 0. Also, a UKI that lacks any
.profile section is treated like one with only a profile 0, but with
no data in that profile section.
3. The stub will first search for its usual set of PE sections
(hereafter called "base sections"), and stop at the first .profile PE
section if any. It will then find the .profile matching the selected
profile by its index, and any sections found as part of that profile
on top of the base sections.
And that's already it.
Example: let's say a distro wants to provide a single UKI that can be
invoked in one of three ways:
1. The regular profile that just boots the system
2. A profile that boots into storagetm
3. A profile that initiates factory reset and reboots.
For this it would define a classic UKI with sections .linux, .initrd,
.cmdline, and whatever else it needs. The .cmdline section would contain
the kernel command line for the regular profile.
It would then insert one ".profile" section, with a contents like the
following:
ID=regular
This is the profile for profile 0. It would immediately afterwards add
another ".profile" section:
ID=storagetm
TITLE=Boot into Storage Target Mode
This would then followed with a .cmdline section that is just like the
basic one, but with "rd.systemd.unit=storage-target-mode.target"
suffixed. Then, another .profile section would be added:
ID=factory-reset
TITLE=Factory Reset
Which is then followed by one last PE section: a .cmdline one with
"systemd.unit=factory-reset.target" suffixed to te regular command line.
i.e. expressed in tabular form the above would be:
The base profile:
.linux
.initrd
.cmdline
.osrel
The regular boot profile:
.profile
The storagetm profile:
.profile
.cmdline
The factory reset profile:
.profile
.cmdline
You might wonder why the first .cmdline in the list above is placed in
the base profile rather than in the regular boot profile, given that it
is overriden in all other profiles anyway. And you are right. The only
reason I'd place it in the base profile is that it makes the UKI more
nicely extensible if later profiles are added that want to replace
something else instead of the .cmdline, for example .ucode or so. But it
really doesn't matter much.
While the primary usecase is of course multiple alternative command
lines, the concept is more powerful than that: for various usecases it
might be valuable to offer multiple choices of devicetree, ucode or
initrds.
The .profile contents is also passed to the invoked kernel as a file in
/.extra/profile (via a synthetic initrd). Thus, this functionality can
even be useful without overriding any section at all, simply by means of
reading that file from userspace.
Design choices:
1. On purposes I used a special command line marker (i.e. the "@" thing,
which maybe we should call the "profile selector"), that doesn't look
like a regular kernel command line option. This is because this is
really not a regular kernel command line option – we process it in
the stub, then remove it as prefix, and measure the unprefixed
command line only after that. The kernel will not see the profile
selector either. I think these special semantics are best
communicated by making it look substantially different from regular
options.
2. This moves around measurements a bit. Previously we measured our UKI
sections right after finding them. Now we first parse the profile
number from the command line, then search for the profile's sections,
and only then measure the sections we actually end up using for this
profile. I think that this logic makes most sense: measure what we
are using, not what we are overriding. Or in other words, if you boot
profile @3, then we'll measure .cmdline (assuming it exists) of
profile 3, and *not* measure .cmdline of the base profile. Also note
that if the user passes in a custom kernel command line via command
line arguments we'll strip off the profile selector (i.e. the initial
"@X" thing) before we pass it on.
3. The .profile stuff is supposed to be generic and extensible. For
example we could use it in future to mark "dangerous" options such as
factory reset, so that boot menus can ask for confirmation before
booting into it. Or we could introduce match expressions against
SMBIOS or other system identifiers, to filter out profiles on
specific hw.
Note btw, that PE allows defining multiple sections that point to the
same offsets in the file. This allows sharing payload under different
names. For example, if profile @4 and @7 shall carry the same .ucode
section, they can define .ucode in each profile and then make it point to
the same offset.
Also note that that one can even "mask" a base section in a profile, by
inserting an empty section. For example, if the base .dtb section should
not be used for profile @4, then add a section .dtb right after the
fourth .profile with a zero size to the UKI, and you will get your wish
fulfilled.
This code only contains changes to sd-stub. A follow-up commit will
teach sd-boot to also find this profile PE sections to synthesize
additional menu entries from a single UKI.
A later commit will add support for gnerating this via ukify.
Fixes: #24539
2024-06-27 23:21:58 +03:00
<varlistentry >
<term > <filename > /.extra/profile</filename> </term>
<term > <filename > /.extra/os-release</filename> </term>
<listitem > <para > The contents of the <literal > .profile</literal> and <literal > .osrel</literal>
sections of the selected profile, if any.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v257" /> </listitem>
</varlistentry>
2022-09-09 12:08:35 +03:00
</variablelist>
<para > Note that all these files are located in the <literal > tmpfs</literal> file system the kernel sets
up for the initrd file hierarchy and are thus lost when the system transitions from the initrd execution
environment into the host file system. If these resources shall be kept around over this transition they
need to be copied to a place that survives the transition first, for example via a suitable
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > tmpfiles.d</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 5</manvolnum> </citerefentry> line. By
default, this is done for the TPM2 PCR signature and public key files.</para>
</refsect1>
2023-01-30 18:26:50 +03:00
<refsect1 >
<title > SMBIOS Type 11 Strings</title>
<para > <command > systemd-stub</command> can be configured using SMBIOS Type 11 strings. Applicable strings
2024-03-10 23:24:52 +03:00
consist of a name, followed by <literal > =</literal> , followed by the value. Unless
<command > systemd-stub</command> detects it is running inside a confidential computing environment,
2023-01-30 18:26:50 +03:00
<command > systemd-stub</command> will search the table for a string with a specific name, and if found,
use its value. The following strings are read:</para>
<variablelist >
<varlistentry >
<term > <varname > io.systemd.stub.kernel-cmdline-extra</varname> </term>
<listitem > <para > If set, the value of this string is added to the list of kernel command line
2023-08-22 19:52:36 +03:00
arguments that are measured in PCR12 and passed to the kernel.</para>
<xi:include href= "version-info.xml" xpointer= "v254" /> </listitem>
2023-01-30 18:26:50 +03:00
</varlistentry>
</variablelist>
</refsect1>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
<refsect1 >
<title > Assembling Kernel Images</title>
2023-01-10 18:00:49 +03:00
<para > In order to assemble a bootable Unified Kernel Image from various components as described above, use
<citerefentry > <refentrytitle > ukify</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> .</para>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</refsect1>
<refsect1 >
<title > See Also</title>
2023-12-22 21:09:32 +03:00
<para > <simplelist type= "inline" >
<member > <citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-boot</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 7</manvolnum> </citerefentry> </member>
<member > <citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd.exec</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 5</manvolnum> </citerefentry> </member>
<member > <citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-creds</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> </member>
<member > <citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-sysext</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 8</manvolnum> </citerefentry> </member>
<member > <ulink url= "https://uapi-group.org/specifications/specs/boot_loader_specification" > Boot Loader Specification</ulink> </member>
<member > <ulink url= "https://systemd.io/BOOT_LOADER_INTERFACE" > Boot Loader Interface</ulink> </member>
<member > <citerefentry > <refentrytitle > ukify</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> </member>
<member > <citerefentry > <refentrytitle > systemd-measure</refentrytitle> <manvolnum > 1</manvolnum> </citerefentry> </member>
<member > <ulink url= "https://systemd.io/TPM2_PCR_MEASUREMENTS" > TPM2 PCR Measurements Made by systemd</ulink> </member>
</simplelist> </para>
2021-09-21 17:52:24 +03:00
</refsect1>
</refentry>